Skip to content
Heating equipment and storage tanks in a utility room
Homeowner guides

Repair or replace a furnace: how to decide

(647) 692-0819Open 24/7, day or night

When a furnace breaks down, the real question is whether to put money into it or toward a new one. This guide explains how to decide whether to repair or replace a furnace using the things that actually settle it: age, the part that failed, safety, how often it breaks down, and what it costs to run. If yours has stopped working, our furnace repair team can diagnose it first, so you decide with facts instead of guesses.

Get an installation quote

Tell us about your home. We’ll call to book a quote visit.

What do you need?
How soon? Optional
Add email, details or text updatesOptional

Or call (647) 692-0819Used only to book your visit. Privacy

Key takeaways

  • Many furnaces last about 15 to 20 years, so a major failure near that age leans toward replacement.
  • Small wear parts like a flame sensor or ignitor are usually worth fixing on a healthy furnace.
  • A cracked heat exchanger is a safety problem: the furnace stays off, and replacement usually follows.
  • Repeat breakdowns, cold rooms and an old mid-efficiency unit all strengthen the case for a new furnace.
  • We price the repair and the replacement side by side, flat-rate, before any work starts.

Last updated . Written and reviewed by the Assurance HVAC Heating & Cooling service team.

On this page
  1. Get a diagnosis before you decide anything
  2. How age changes whether to repair or replace a furnace
  3. Which failed parts are worth fixing
  4. A cracked heat exchanger is a safety decision
  5. Repair history: how many winters in a row?
  6. Efficiency and gas bills when you repair or replace a furnace
  7. Comfort problems a repair won’t solve
  8. What is the $5,000 rule for a furnace?
  9. Repair or replace a furnace: weigh the factors together
  10. When a repair is the sensible choice
  11. What a good furnace replacement includes
  12. Should you price a heat pump at the same time?
  13. How we help you repair or replace a furnace
  14. If you repair, help the furnace last
  15. Repair or replace a furnace: common questions

Get a diagnosis before you decide anything

You can’t make a good call until you know exactly what failed and what shape the rest of the furnace is in. A no-heat breakdown might be a part that wears out on every furnace, or it might be the first sign of a furnace near the end of its life. The diagnosis tells you which.

How age changes whether to repair or replace a furnace

Age is the first filter. Many gas furnaces last about 15 to 20 years with regular care, so a furnace under about 10 years old is usually worth repairing, while one past 15 deserves a hard look at replacement before any major repair.

Age alone doesn’t settle it. A well-kept furnace in a dry, clean basement can outlast one that ran on clogged filters for years. What age really changes is the odds: on an older unit, the next part to fail is rarely far behind the one you just paid to fix.

Which failed parts are worth fixing

The part that failed matters almost as much as the furnace’s age. Some parts wear out on every furnace and are routine to swap, while others are the costly core of the system. A small part on a sound furnace points to a repair; a major part on an aging one tips the balance toward replacement.

How the part that failed usually points the decision
Part that failedWhat it doesUsual verdict
Flame sensorProves the burners actually litClean or replace it; worth fixing at almost any age
Hot surface ignitorGlows hot to light the burnersA routine wear part; repair
Pressure switchConfirms the venting is clear before ignitionRepair, once the reason it tripped is found
Inducer motorPulls exhaust out through the vent pipeUsually repair; compare prices on an older unit
Blower or ECM motorPushes heated air through the ductsRepair on a younger furnace; weigh it on an old one
Control boardRuns the whole heating sequenceRepair if young; often the trigger to replace an old furnace
Heat exchangerKeeps combustion gases out of your airA crack usually means replacement

A cracked heat exchanger is a safety decision

A cracked heat exchanger takes the choice out of your hands. The heat exchanger is the metal chamber that keeps burning gases apart from the air your blower sends through the house, so a crack or hole can let combustion gases, carbon monoxide included, into that air. The furnace has to stay off.

Technicians look for cracks, rust-through and scorching around the burners, and watch whether the flame wavers when the blower starts. On an older furnace, the cost of a new heat exchanger and the wait for it usually make a new furnace the better spend.

Whatever you decide, keep carbon monoxide alarms working. Ontario’s Fire Code requires a CO alarm next to every sleeping area and, since January 1, 2026, on every storey of any home with a fuel-burning appliance, a fireplace or an attached garage, as the province’s carbon monoxide safety page (opens in a new tab) explains. If an alarm sounds, get everyone, pets included, outside and call 911.

Repair history: how many winters in a row?

A furnace that needs a technician every winter is telling you something. One repair in several years is normal wear, but two or three breakdowns in a short stretch, especially on different parts, usually means the whole furnace is wearing out at once, and more failures are coming.

Keep the invoices, or at least a note of each date and part. Patterns show up quickly: an ignitor this year, the inducer last year, a board the year before. Each looked sensible alone, but together they bought little extra life.

Efficiency and gas bills when you repair or replace a furnace

Efficiency is where an old furnace quietly costs you every month. Every new gas furnace sold in Canada is now a condensing model rated 95% AFUE or higher, while many furnaces still running in GTA basements are mid-efficiency units of around 80% AFUE that vent into a metal flue or chimney.

AFUE is the share of the gas you buy that becomes heat over a season. Moving from around 80% to 95% or better means less of each cubic metre goes up the flue, though how much you save depends on the house, its insulation and how you run the thermostat.

Switching from mid-efficiency also means new plastic venting out a side wall and a condensate drain, and both belong in the replacement quote.

Comfort problems a repair won’t solve

Some complaints have nothing to do with a broken part. If the house swings between warm and chilly, the far bedrooms never catch up, or the furnace roars every time it starts, a repair brings the heat back but leaves those comfort problems where they were.

Older single-stage furnaces run flat out every cycle. A two-stage or modulating furnace with an ECM blower spends most of its time at lower output, which evens out temperatures and runs more quietly. That’s a fair reason to replace a furnace already near the end, but not a young one.

Not every comfort issue is the furnace’s fault. Leaky ducts or a missing return upstairs can make any furnace feel weak, and dry winter air is a job for a humidifier, which our indoor air quality team adds to your existing furnace.

What is the $5,000 rule for a furnace?

The $5,000 rule is a rough rule of thumb often quoted when deciding whether to repair or replace a furnace. Multiply the furnace’s age in years by the repair quote in dollars. If the result is more than 5,000, a replacement is usually worth pricing; if it’s under 5,000, the repair usually makes sense.

The older the furnace, the smaller the repair that crosses the line, which matches how the odds change with age. It’s a starting point, not a verdict: it leaves out safety, efficiency, comfort and what a replacement would cost, so use it alongside the checklist below.

A cracked heat exchanger overrides the arithmetic, because the furnace stays off whatever the numbers say. And since we price the repair and a replacement side by side, flat-rate, you can run the rule on real quotes instead of guesses.

Repair or replace a furnace: weigh the factors together

Most decisions come down to several factors pointing the same way. Use the table below as a checklist: if most of your answers land in the replacing column, a new furnace deserves serious thought, and if most land in the repairing column, fixing it is usually money well spent.

Signs that point toward repairing or replacing
FactorPoints to repairingPoints to replacing
AgeWell short of 15 yearsClose to or beyond 15 to 20 years
What brokeA wear part such as a sensor, ignitor or capacitorThe heat exchanger, or a board or motor on an old unit
SafetyNothing unsafe foundA cracked heat exchanger or venting that can’t be made safe
BreakdownsFirst real problem in yearsA repair call most winters
EfficiencyAlready a condensing modelMid-efficiency, venting up the chimney
ComfortRooms heat evenly once it runsCold rooms, big swings, loud starts
PartsEasy to getDiscontinued or slow to arrive
Your plansMoving in the next year or twoStaying put for many winters

When a repair is the sensible choice

Repair is usually right when the furnace is comfortably within its expected life, the failure is a single wear part, and the inspection raises no safety concern. In that case a repair restores reliable heat for far less than a new furnace, and you can still replace it later on your own schedule.

Repair also makes sense when replacing would be rushed. Choosing a furnace during a cold snap, with no time to compare sizing and options, is how homes end up with the wrong one. A repair that gets you through winter buys time to plan one for the spring.

What a good furnace replacement includes

If replacement wins, the new furnace should be sized for your home as it is now, not copied from the old one’s label. That means a heat-loss calculation, a check of the ducts and venting, and a clear quote covering removal of the old unit, the new venting and drain, and the permits and inspections the job needs.

Ask the quote to name the model, its AFUE, whether it’s single-stage, two-stage or modulating, and the blower type. Our furnace replacement page covers sizing and options in depth.

Should you price a heat pump at the same time?

If your central air conditioner is about as old as the furnace, price a cold-climate heat pump too. Paired with a gas furnace as backup, a heat pump heats the house on milder days, leaves the furnace for the coldest nights of a GTA winter, and cools it in summer.

For rebates, look at heat pumps. The Home Renovation Savings Program from Save on Energy and Enbridge Gas offers rebates on eligible heat pumps, with amounts that depend on the home and its current heating fuel. See the program details (opens in a new tab), our rebates page and our heat pump installation options.

How we help you repair or replace a furnace

When you call, a TSSA-certified gas technician diagnoses the furnace and gives you a flat-rate price for the repair and, on an older unit, a price for a replacement beside it. You approve whichever you choose before any work starts, and both come with our written workmanship warranty.

Booked visits get a two-hour arrival window and a text, we work on all major brands, and we’re open 24/7 if the heat is out tonight. Book a visit to get both prices in hand.

If you repair, help the furnace last

A repaired furnace lasts longer with steady care. Change the filter on schedule, keep supply and return vents open and unblocked, and keep the intake and exhaust pipes outside clear of snow. A yearly tune-up catches worn parts before a no-heat call in January.

Our maintenance plan includes two tune-ups a year, so a technician checks the heat exchanger and safety controls regularly and you see a replacement coming.

FAQ

Repair or replace a furnace: common questions

How long does a furnace last in a GTA home?

Many gas furnaces last about 15 to 20 years. How long yours lasts depends on how well it was sized and installed, how often the filter was changed and whether it had regular tune-ups. An oversized furnace that short cycles, or one that ran for years on clogged filters, tends to wear out sooner.

Is it worth repairing a 20-year-old furnace?

Sometimes, for a small part. If a 20-year-old furnace needs a flame sensor or ignitor and passes a safety inspection, a repair can get you through the winter while you plan. For a control board, a motor or anything involving the heat exchanger, replacement is usually the better spend at that age.

Should I replace my furnace if the heat exchanger is cracked?

In almost every case, yes. A crack can let carbon monoxide into the air the furnace circulates, so the furnace must stay off. On a younger furnace, ask whether the part is still under the manufacturer’s warranty, though labour and the wait still apply. Keep CO alarms working meanwhile.

Can I keep running my old furnace while I decide?

If the technician found nothing unsafe, yes. A working furnace can usually keep heating while you compare options. The exceptions are a cracked heat exchanger, a venting fault or anything the technician marks as unsafe, which stay off. If a CO alarm sounds, get everyone, pets included, outside and call 911.

Will a new furnace lower my gas bills?

If you’re replacing a mid-efficiency furnace, the new one should use less gas for the same heat, since every new gas furnace sold in Canada is rated 95% AFUE or higher. How much you notice depends on the house, its insulation and how you use the thermostat, so we don’t promise a number.

Is it better to repair or replace a furnace in the middle of winter?

If the furnace is safe and the fix is simple, repairing mid-winter is often smarter, because it restores heat quickly and lets you plan a replacement properly later. If the furnace is unsafe, or the repair is a major part on an old unit, replacing it now makes more sense.

Do you give both a repair price and a replacement price?

Yes. On an older furnace, the technician gives you a flat-rate price for the repair and a price for a properly sized replacement, side by side. We explain which way we’d lean and why, but the choice stays yours, and nothing starts until you approve it.

How can I find out how old my furnace is?

Start with any paperwork from the installer or the previous owner, or look for a service sticker on the outside of the cabinet. The manufacture date is usually coded into the serial number on the rating plate, and a technician can read it for you at the next visit.

Book a visit

Planning a replacement? We’ll call you back to book a quote visit.

Send the form or call. You’ll get a confirmed arrival window and a price before any work starts.

(647) 692-0819

Open 24/7, with technicians out day or night for no-heat and no-cooling emergencies

Get an installation quote

Tell us about your home. We’ll call to book a quote visit.

What do you need?
How soon? Optional
Add an email or detailsOptional

Or call (647) 692-0819Used only to book your visit. Privacy